The Elephant in the Brain
Note · updated
There are things we try to avoid thinking about that actually explain our actions
To test this, reverse engineer our motives from our actions.
Playing politics is effective, but so is honesty. How can we have both?
Our brains hide our Machiavellianism from us
4 strands of research which suggest this
Brains choreograph social status even if we aren't thinking
The mind acts to distort ourselves
Primatology - Machiavellian behaviour, something doesn't add up
Institutions show similar confusion
Counter theories
Thesis
People are judging us all the time
We downplay our ugly motives
We deceive ourself better to deceive others
Sometimes we call this out in others, sometimes we dont'
Other notes
Primate grooming
Observations
Counter observations
Humans don't really engage in group grooming even though we like having hÌeads scratched, hands massaged, pimples popped, hair braided
Authors choose their examples selectively to make their case
Potential hypotheses
It's about social trust, not grooming
It's a way of offering fealty
You can eat the bugs
Other grooming is more efficient so little self grooming happens