Linked references · 6
A high schooler asked for advice on how to get involved in EA . My response (here) got a high score and several people got in touch to say they liked it. I reproduce it below, slightly edited:
Open Philanthropy's Worldview Diversification is currently broken. As Richard Y Chappell points out. The worldviews aren't actually worldviews. In my view, they are Cause areas, baking in something which shouldn't be baked in. EA should be Cause neutral, but hard-coded cause areas aren't.
I find much EA criticism to be bunk, but some of it is good. Here I will reference criticisms I think have merit:
The vibe of EA is that criticism is underrated and so we should have more of it regardless of quality. A sort of general subsidy for criticism. For a long time I felt this way myself. That I should praise anyone criticising EA (or to a lesser extent me) because I wanted people to feel free to criticise.
I wonder if this is more like supply and demand, about supplying criticism that people demand. And correcting a status market - EA is too high status, let's fix it.
Yes no - why not? Have you tried applying for Effective Altruism money?
Wanting to think well isn't the same as doing it. Effective Altruisms want to think well. Here is some evidence: