Two worldviews
- A pair of blogs on English politics and Christianity
- First blog
- The English Conservative Evangelical Worldview
- A study of one of the worldviews of my family and friends
- Theory
- The country is going to the dogs
- Evidence
- mental illness/anxiety,
- no national identity
- less focus on family
- LGBT+
- Low growth
- Counter evidence
- Britain is still a safe wealthy country
- Theory
- Nations that turn away from God suffer.
- Evidence
- Bible
- Selective reading of history
- Counter evidence
- Perhaps an acknowledgement that God's plans are mysterious
- If Christianity is better, why don't people believe it?
- Theory
- People don't want the hard medicine
- Evidence
- Counter evidence
- Some notion that in some way non-Christians lives are harder
- Some similarities to hard times weak mean analogy
- Context
- God loves us and has created a way for us ot live
- Humanity is sinful
- Jesus died to forgive sin
- There are laws for a good nation
- Not following them leads to the world we see
- A christian remnant survives
- Weaknesses of the argument
- Circular reasoning on what is good - LGBT+ is bad because of the bible but this is evidence that Britian is doing badly because it has turned away
- Little actual scholarship of what causes nations to succeed. Is the US very Christian, or China? They are doing well. Not clear there is an actual standard here.
- Much of this isn't load bearing, seems like they would believe this even in a very successful non-Christain country
- Doesn't deal with harms created
- More general issues with Christianity
- Second blog
- A comparison between evangelical Christianity and [choose a name for my thoughts]
- To me it's about which story better explains the world I see
- Evolution
- Unlikely, clear steps
- Genetic selection
- Humans coordinating and competing
- Complex social structures and technology
- Requires trust in many steps and institutions
- Christianity
- God can't abide by sin
- God creates humans
- God give free will
- Humans choose sin
- Jesus died to forgive sin and bring humans back into relationship with God
- Some accept
- Some refuse and suffer eternal torment
- Focuses on personal faith
- Conflict
- Prefer falsifiable things
- when I check evolution I find it makes sense
- When I check Christianity I find more confusion
- Do you choose something falsifiablewith like a 0.00001% chance or something unfalsifiable with a only 1 huge question
- We don't have good concepts for likelihood
- Evolution feels unlikely because our brains perform well at imagining people, but under a scientific worldview evolution is simpler than imagining some all powerful conscious deity
- God's justice doesn't make sense to me
- God builds pit with a weak edge and says don't stand near it
- I do
- I fall in
- Jesus comes across the sea and saves me
- I am expected to be grateful
- There are two way to look at this story, either it's obvious I should be grateful or it's cosmic guilt tripping on the part of God.
- And this is before we get into adam and eve (why am I punished for their sin?) or creation (I didn't decide to be born?)
- I am not sure what Chrisitanity explains that evolution doesn't
- Evolution explains why we see many of the specific thigns we do - differences between creatures
- What does chrisitanity explain above this?
- Already have explanations for selfishness and hope, and I don't find the gospels particularly hard to explain
- If I imagine that this weren't the case, that the bible formed a single self-consistent moral account, would i be more intrested? A bit.
- In some sense I am oopen to the idea that a god is real and one day I will face judgement, but I can't say I respect the guy.
- If the moral calculus made sense then maybe I would feel more like taking a punt on christianity?
- But I think I'd still say, what needs to be explained here?