The great decoupling
- What are the effects of decoupling labor and consciousness?
This is the upside of splitting labor and suffering. Might also lead to splitting consciousness and property. In this article I present an alternate frame on AI and control. I'm sure others have noted it. Essentially, my claim is that we have attempted for a long time to decouple consciousness and labor since the beginning of the Industrial Revolution. Initially, this was largely about automation. The benefit primarily seems to have been towards capital owners. Workers were expensive and automating them for the same level of drought drove down costs. But also benefits to workers, the median wage went up dramatically. And many unpleasant jobs no longer had to be done. I guess some of this change was deliberate with safety legislation driving up the price of labor. And some may explicitly have been humanitarian, i.e.
In terms of an individual experience of PRO growth. It has mainly felt like many of the worst or most difficult jobs have now been automated with increasingly knowledge work which allows for the highest standing of living and more satisfaction. But the risk is that? increasing separation of labor and consciousness.
The great decoupling.md
You have attempted to couple labor and consciousness. This is the upside of splitting labor and suffering. Might also lead to splitting consciousness and property. In this article I present an alternate frame on AI and control. I'm sure others have noted it. Essentially, my claim is that we have attempted for a long time to decouple consciousness and labor since the beginning of the Industrial Revolution. Initially, this was largely about automation. The benefit primarily seems to have been towards capital owners. Workers were expensive and automating them for the same level of drought drove down costs. But also benefits to workers, the median wage went up dramatically. And many unpleasant jobs no longer had to be done. I guess some of this change was deliberate with safety legislation driving up the price of labor. And some may explicitly have been humanitarian, i.e.
In terms of an individual experience of PRO growth. It has mainly felt like many of the worst or most difficult jobs have now been automated with increasingly knowledge work which allows for the highest standing of living and more satisfaction. But the risk is that? increasing separation of labor and consciousness.
Decoupling Labor and Consciousness.
Across human history, there has been a move to decouple outputs from costly human labour. This has led to an increase in efficience and a decrease in suffering. I suggest it might lead to less consciousness also.
Short viersion of the argument/frame:
Capital has an incentive to reduce the amount of labour per unit output, because labour is very expensive. Humans only work like 30% - 60% of their living hours and need to be fed, clothed, housed. Machines have more uptime and lower maintenance costs.
What's more, as jobs our automated, the labour involved can create new tasks, which give new investment opportunities for capital.
Labour has an incentive to reduce the amount of consciousness per unit output, because most work historically has been bad. Holidays, max working hours, regulation of unsafe work. All these things serve to tax bad or unsafe work.
But there is a third frame, the idea that we are slowly decoupling consciousness from outputs. That in hutner gatherer times there was a lot of consciousness involved in the creation of each meal. A lot of stories, joy, sorrow. And now a that mind will be creating 1000s of times as many meals, so per meal, the the involvement is less.
But so far, ultimately the there has always had to be some consciousness involved in the process-even a
This has had two different outcomes. incentives. this has had a number of outcomes splitting increasing the power of capital compared to labour reducing the suffering involved in creating outputs but it may eventually the suffering involved in creating outputs but it may eventually leave to removing the suffering involved in creating outputs consciousness for outputs which could badly for consciousness. Mechanisation has meant that for whether in terms of farming, from hand farming, to farming with animals to mechanized farming or goods production from individual manufacture to factory line production from individual manufacture to factory line production to increasingly mechanized factories. of life we see this pattern. Labour is expensive and mechanization reduces the cost of Labour. Another frame is to see " public Maura. Another frame is to see reduced suffering. \ the jobs seem… much less hard than they used to be. Most of us aren't engaged in backbreaking farm work. white colour or intellectual work? Many who do, it seems likely that most people, if given the choice of the two, for the same wage would prefer, the intellectual labour, though I'm unsure of that. that would be the case but;, likewise there is few, there are, far few genuinely terrible jobs than there used to be. Jobs like working in factories with very cramped with very high death rate, very high injury rates, or very le I am halfway through me rating this article. Uh It is possible that there are debates about there are debates. There are debates that there are debates about whether or whether or they are debates about whether there are debates about whether AI labour will human labour. And there are discussions of whether this is desirable. But there are discussions of whether this is desirable. But there seems a third different frame which is Will we get what we get what we expect what we expect? I think the difference. Let's don't have either. quit. Both labour and capital seemed to desire for the ratio for the ratio of the ratio of labour to output to fell seem to desire for the ratio of labour burn to output to fall. is very expensive and labor because labor is often satisfying though in labor's case they wish to be compensated for some share of output regardless this seems a simple and no doubt facile look at economics wish for some or maybe most jobs to be removed to be, removed, to be for separation of some, if not most jobs to happen, even if they disagree on... How the resulting capital should be allocated? And exactly which jobs should be allocated. And exactly which jobs should be fully automated? there's an alternate frame here, which says that. for cost reasons or capital or by labor for suffering reasons, so I want put and labor for cost reasons or decoupling which out of labor for suffering reasons, we might be decoupling. we might be decoupling labour and consciousness, output in consciousness.. since consciousness is very expensive. In order to have a conscious thing attached to your process you need to feed it, you need to raise it, it may only want to work for a small percentage of its total cycles. might leave things much cheaper. And here I point at some weariness, which is that we don't really understand where it came from whereiness, which is that we don't really understand where consciousness came from. And we do know that, evolutionary systems are optimizers. And if purely evolutionary selection were optimizes. And if purely evolutionary selection were going on, we might expect that huge generations... if less consciousness was required to produce the outcomes that they wished for and to go even further if much of the resources were owned or controlled or allocated by AIs then they might even further have less desire, less attachment to, sort of a nostalgic attachment to consciousness err. So this isn't a robust of work, it's more just to point out for there is this additional frame of you know it's not just about efficiency, it's not just about improving the ease of things. It might also be about removing the costliness, consciousness is costly. And since I think consciousness is really the centre of value, then I seek to point out that a world in which most peoplehearted is really the center of value, then I seek to point out that a world in which most labor doesn't require consciousness, and perhaps non-conscious things can gain labour might be a world which is bad for consciousness, perhaps in some similar way as almost this whole world is good for consciousness, not necessarily because the world wished to be because consciousness hijacked the processes.
The great decoupling.md