The other day, I wrote "Puerto Rico's lack of statehood strikes me as profoundly unamerican. It is full of American citizens... who get taxed... but don't get represented." This got viewed 130k times and even got Communnity Notes-ed.
Reading the comments it seems that I, and commenter, were mistaken about several aspects, but overall the point is correct.
First, Puerto Rico isn't a state. I was correct about this.
Many people said that Puerto Rico had voted not to become a state. According to wikipedia, there have been 5 votes. The first two showed plurality support for options other than statehood. The next two showed, in my view, weak support for statehood (weak first because of a complicated quesiton, the second because statehood opponents boycotted) the final vote in 2020, was 52% for statehood. Puerto Rico has voted in favour of statehood.
It does seem like Puerto Ricans might prefer a commonwealth or some other non-state, non-status quo option. I am unsure what this means.
Next, Puerto Ricans do not get representation in Congress.
Finally then, taxation. Are Puerto Ricans federally taxed?
But the overall point is correct. Puerto Ricans are US citizens who are taxed but not represented in the federal government.
If people in the US in the 1700 were taxed less than the UK (plausibly true, I have little idea) would they not have seceeded? I doubt many Americans would argue this point. The point is that one should have the ability to vote aroudn taxes applied in one's country.
It seems plausible to me that for some wealthy people Puerto Rico is a good deal. But I imagine for most citizens it is not. If there were electoral votes and seats in Congress, I guess that Democrats would care about Puerto Ricans a little more and Republicans a lot more. I guess this would lead to higher quality of life for the median Puerto Rican.