Forecasts provide a valuable source of information
Betting is a legitimate means of forecasting
Betting does not mean that those betting don't take it seriously
Forecasting ugly outcomes is generally taxed way to high by our culture
Betting on war is often good, as it currently exists. This isn't a motte and bailey. I'm not going to talk about idealised betting in an idealised world. I mean that the current setup is good and beneficial.
I'll start with my strongest argument.
Just want to say that I moved from Kyiv to Lviv on Feb 13 /entirely/ thanks to this prediction thread and the Metaculus estimates. (Still in Lviv but leaving Ukraine later today.)
It’s hard to estimate the impact, but at the very least I have saved myself an enormous hassle trying to move all my possessions, finding an apartment in Lviv, etc on very short notice — which would have happened otherwise. Of course, worse outcomes were possible too if things had played out a bit differently.
A forecast on the Ukraine invasion allowed availablegreen (I guess a young man) to leave his home and make better choices than he would otherwise have done. Had the invasion gone much worse for Ukraine, it could have saved him a much more traumatic experience.
Whatever we think the costs of war betting are, this is one of the benefits. An actual person was saved a huge amount of trouble.
If you like examples, I have put more at the end. But let's now make the more robust case. It has 3 points:
Forecasts provide a valuable source of information
Betting is a legitimate means of forecasting
Betting does not mean that those betting don't take it seriously
Forecasts provide a valuable source of information
Betting is a legitimate means of forecasting
Betting does not mean that those betting don't take it seriously
[^1]: I guess