Discourse
- Discourse is when people are talking about a thing. Sometimes I capitalise it, to refer to the twitter discourse that is happening right now - The Discourse
- We could get an AI to summarise our points
- This could already be built, right?
- What is good discourse?
- When people more quickly or less costlily come to opinions they will later endorse
- Analogies
- Heat. Opinions are like heat. On any issue, some are hot, some are cold. Some environments are like conductors, where people converge on the average opinion. Some are like insulators, where people don't. (Also, confusingly for the analogy in some environments all participants end up hotter than they started, which isn't possible for temperature)
- Energy surface. There is a big multi-dimensional energy surface. Discourse is like a ball sitting on this surface. Often it looks like it is in a stable equilibrium, but there is some previously hidden direction in which it can roll.
- Examples:
- Brexit It turned out that there was a huge amount of support for Brexit, which had been discounted. This is equivalent to potential energy (like a ball on a hill) or some kind of fossil fuel discovery. Once the discussion happened, the Leave side became more and more powerful as this previously hidden support came to light.
- Is good discourse finding these hidden directions and making them visible?
- To change your mind, it's good to feel psychologically safe.
- People you know and trust
- Anonymity
- Strong unified norms
- Costs for being wrong
- It is probably good to cut down the things disagreed on.
- Figure out agreement
- Find empirical questions and answer them
- What is wrong with discourse?
- People are mistaken about reality
- People are discussing something as a leisure activity, rather than as a focused task
- Poor forecasting
- The discussion is filled with with people who have bad discussion norms
- People are seeking status, not to be correct
- People have different discussion culture and rub one another up the wrong way
- Questions
- What is good discourse?
- What kind of discourse do I want to improve?
- Is discourse the space in which conversation happens, the act of discussing or something else?
- This whole discussion feels ungrounded somehow.
- Suggestions
- Leaderboards of the above
- Prizes
- Surveys of what people are wrong about and then public education campaigns
- Have orgs to find out empircal questions - Our World In Data Epoch
- Divorcing people from their views
- Anon google doc
- Ideological Turing Test eg Give everyone some points to pretend are their own, noone is expected to be giving their honest views
- Chatham Room
- Figure out agreement between disagreeing parties - Viewpoints
- Longform suggested discourse projects
- Create a leaderboard of Kalshi and Polymarket and allow users to attach their names to them. Show the first 100.
- The aim would be to create status in people doing extremely well in prediction markets.
- Predictionmarketleaderboard.com or PredicitonMarket100.com
- Allow other users to search for their position
- Twitter log ins. Polymarket logins? Have me do it by hand.
- Filter just by public figures (What's a public figure? some number of followers on some platform?)
- Biggest losers?
- Build a chatbot to explain AI X-risk
- Many people probably still don't understand it. There are better and worse arguments and a chatbot can be supplied with the better ones.
- Why would someone use this chatbot rather than Stampy?
- Quicker replies
- More accurate answers
- A site to show what prediction markets currently say about AI.
- Curate some
- Have an LLM that searches through them
- How much do people use Adam binks thing?
- Can I get a rich text download
- Run discourse sessions/ debates